There are two versions, but neither of them do ReWire . . . THOUGHTSThe advanced version costs approximately $299 (US); but as noted, neither version does ReWire, which in a practical way maps to being unusable with NOTION 6 directly . . .
NOTION External MIDI staves can send MIDI via a virtual MIDI cable, but without ReWire there is no synchronization, which for all practical purposes makes it useless . . .
The idea of being focused on emulating the analog universe digitally is
intriguing, but whether this makes sense in a practical way is another matter . . .
[
NOTE: In the real world of physical mixing boards or consoles, there is a range of specific sonic characteristics, and when you add digital but nevertheless physical mixing boards, the range increases. From the perspective of software engineering, each DAW application has specific sonic characteristics, and as explained in the following observations, the overall "sound" of each DAW application is different in this respect. Yet, since there are decisions made in software engineering regarding the way audio is handled via algorithms, it's not so easy to guess whether "analog warmth" is a primary or secondary criterion. My impression at present is that there are two general design criteria in this respect, where one is focused on what one might call "purity" and the other is focused on what one might call "bias" or "flavoring"; and in practice each DAW application probably is designed and programmed with consideration for both perspectives or sonic styles. Relevant to this observation is the fact that "purity" maps to observing the rules of acoustic physics in terms of mathematics and physical physics, while "bias" or "flavoring" is focused on the perceptual aspects of acoustic physics. Explained another way, vacuum tubes are warm and blurry, so they affect the way everything sounds. This can be done in the digital universe, but it's not an absolute requirement. With vacuum tubes, there is no other option; but there are many options in the digital universe--especially considering that when you play the music through a calibrated full-range studio monitor system or listen to the music with studio quality headphones, it's all analog, since loudspeakers, subwoofers, and headphones are analog devices and follow the rules of physics discovered several centuries ago by Sir Isaac Newton . . . ]
Nevertheless, as I observed in a different topic, it's obvious to me that different digital mixing boards or consoles have distinct sonic characteristics--something I base primarily on experimenting with Cubase Elements (Steinberg), Digital Performer (MOTU), Live (Ableton), Logic Pro X (Apple), Reaper (Cockos), and Studio One (PreSonus), although primarily Digital Performer and Studio One in terms of hundreds of hours, if not thousands of hours, since my focus on the other Digital Audio Workstation (DAW) applications primarily is to determine whether they do ReWire (which all of them do) and more recently to determine whether they also do ReWire MIDI with NOTION 6 (which
only Studio One and NOTION do) . . .
I also have used Reason (Propellerhead Software) extensively, starting with Reason 5; and it has a mixing board or console, hence in some respects is a DAW application, although
not in the same way as the other DAW applications (
see above), primarily because at least through Reason 9, it only works as a ReWire slave . . .
[
NOTE: I suppose it's possible that Reason 10 can act as a ReWire host controller, but I have not checked this and generally think it doesn't act as a ReWire host controller. (UPDATE) I checked the Reason 10 documentation, and based on what I found Reason 10 only works as a ReWire slave, so nothing new in this regard, except that it supports ReWire 2 to some level, although apparently not to the level that PreSonus products support ReWire 2, specifically with respect to PreSonus products doing ReWire MIDI, which as best as I can determine currently is unique to PreSonus products. If you want to do ReWire MIDI, then PreSonus products (NOTION and Studio One Professional) are the way to do this. ReWire MIDI truly is amazing, since Studio One can host all the virtual instruments (native and third-party, which on the Mac includes both AU [Apple] and VST [Steinberg]), which maps to NOTION only needing to have ReWire MIDI staves and no virtual instruments (native or third-party), with this in turn mapping to NOTION being optimally efficient with low system resource overhead, because it only needs to do the music notation and real-time conversion of music notation to MIDI, which it sends to Studio One via ReWire MIDI pipes . . . ]
The big question, of course, is how MixBus (Harrison) sounds in terms of its sonic characteristics . . .
The MixBus versions are digital, as are the other DAW applications (
see above), but based on the premise that each DAW application has an unique sonic characteristic, this is intriguing . . .
If there were a Pop Quiz and the question was to describe my impression of the sonic characteristics of the mixing boards of each of the DAW applications listed in this post (except MixBus, which I have not used, so far), then my answer is that with the exceptions of Live (Ableton) and Studio One (PreSonus), they are more along the lines of warm and perhaps like what one might expect when working with vacuum tube based technology--which literally and physically is
analog . . .
It's been a while since I have done anything with Live (Ableton), but my recollection is that it is in what I call the "clean, crisp, tolerant" category, although
not so much as Studio One Professional 4 . . .
I prefer "clean, crisp, tolerant", and this is one of the reasons Studio One Professional 4 is now my "goto" DAW application . . .
The "tolerant" aspect refers to being able to add more tracks without needing to remix everything, and in some respects this is a bit subtle, allthough once you realize the importance it's very obvious . . .
When a mixing board is
not "tolerant", each time you add a new track you need to revisit the entire mix and at least all the volume levels for all the track sliders . . .
My experience over the past few months with Studio One suggests that this mostly is
not necessary with Studio One, which is the reason I use "tolerant" in this context . . .
The reason "clean and crisp" are important is equally subtle; and the high-level version is that I have a lot of high-quality third-party effects plug-ins that emulate vacuum tube hardware, mostly T-RackS 5 (IK Multimedia) and a few others, which I use to add what I call "vacuum tube warmth" and at times a bit of "vacuum tube blur", the latter being mostly to enhance deep bass and singing . . .
Explained another way, when a digital mixing board basically is "warm", it complicates the producing and audio engineering when using vacuum tube emulating effects plug-ins, which instead of being (a) adding vacuum tube warmth to clean and crisp becomes (b) adding vacuum tube warmth and blur to already warm and blurry. . .
In other words, it's like reverberation and echoes in the sense that it's easy to add them but nearly impossible to removed them when they are embedded in already-recorded audio . . .
When I want vacuum tube warmth or blur, I can add it in Studio One; but if I don't want it, then it's not there, which is the "clean and crisp" aspect . . .
In some respects, this is a bit subtle; but here in the sound isolation studio I want to control everything ruthlessly, and I can do this with Studio One and NOTION, as well occasionally with some real electric guitar . . .
If I want something to be vacuum tube warm, then I make it vacuum tube warm; but when I don't want vacuum tube warm, it's not there by design, which makes using and controlling vacuum tube warmth and blur a decision I make rather than a decision arbitrarily made by the DAW application, which is where "clean, crisp, tolerant" becomes
paramount here in the sound isolation studio . . .
I am curious to discover the sonic characteristic' footprint(s) of the MixBus DAW application(s); but without support for ReWire, this mostly is a curiosity type of thing here in the sound isolation studio . . .
As time allows, I plan to download the MixBus demo and do some experiments with it . . .
Lots of FUN!